Tzan wrote:So the results are
FAIL at 16% , 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 +1d6
I think a d12 would be preferred.
Critical failure's actually up around 33% - but so is success.
Sounds a lot more complicated than 1d6+3 if you ask me, even if you're guaranteed to roll at least a 4. It's (supposed to be) rare enough that I think a little bit of unfairness is okay.