Awesome figs (pikemen, Shinypants, dark warriors, the green guy...), awesome action. I'm surprised you guys would take so much time to pose the figs in a battle of this scale. The human's hero also redefined luckiness there, Brockram has nothing on him
You bent the rules all to your liking, didn't you? First the "grand dispel!" that cripples the enemy severely, then the levitated javelin suicide, the "bowmen on the stick"-heroic feat and finally the dropping elephant out of the blue, all these worked in your favor. When your units critfail they only loose their weapons or flee the battlefield but don't die. So my judgement: Victory by massive abuse of the Rule of Fudge!